ADA Shortlist
Candidates worth investigating against our own desktop-agent evaluation framework.
This shortlist of ADA candidates reflects our opinion, based on public documentation and provider claims assessed against our ADA benchmark. We have not installed or tested these products, and we have not independently verified that any meets our ADA benchmark. Inclusion reflects our research priorities and interests, not an endorsement or a benchmark pass. Candidates below can cover different parts of the workflow. This is not a scored ranking. Full ADA self-hosting remains unverified for every candidate below.
The ADA benchmark
The ADA benchmark is our own evaluation framework for desktop agents, not an industry standard.
An autonomous desktop agent observes a person’s everyday work and suggests repetitive actions to automate. The user reviews and corrects each proposal before a trial.
- Observe ordinary Windows work
- Find repetition and propose a microtask
- Let the user correct the procedure and approve a trial
- Use AI on a changed case and verify the result
- Reuse approved microtasks and test combined workflows
- Run unattended and report exceptions
- Support fully self-hosted data, AI and execution
Price is a separate consideration. An end-to-end match needs evidence across the same workflow, including a successful run on a changed case.
| Candidate | Why we shortlisted it | Evidence still needed |
|---|---|---|
| Automation Anywhere Process Discovery, Automation 360 and Automator AI | Provider documentation covers discovering repetition in desktop activity and developing reusable automation with AI fallback. | One mined task taken through user correction and trial approval, successful AI adaptation to a changed case, verified business results, combined microtasks and unattended exception reporting. |
| Mimica Miner, Mapper and Maker | Provider describes discovery, process mapping and agent generation with approval and unfamiliar-case alerts. See all seven criterion assessments. | A completed Windows workflow showing procedure correction, changed-case AI execution and independent result verification, reuse of approved microtasks, combined-workflow tests and unattended exceptions. |
| Mediar | Its provider-described pilot centres on reviewing and correcting recorded actions, replaying workflows and checking outputs across input cases. | Discovery and proposals from ordinary work, rather than a chosen recording; completed changed-case evidence, verified outcomes, tested microtask composition and unattended exception handling. |
| OpenAdapt | Its repository documents approval of compiled procedures, reusable execution, saved-record checks and stops for uncertainty. | Automatic repetition discovery and proposals; Windows evidence connecting changed-case AI repair to approval and verified results; tested combined workflows and sustained unattended operation. Local replay alone does not establish local AI for learning and repair. |
| UiPath Task Mining and execution components | Documentation covers task capture, collaborative trace correction and automation export; our comparison also considers its authoring and robot components. | The reviewed Task Mining configuration captures known tasks. We need discovery-to-execution evidence across the same approved workflow, including changed-case adaptation, outcome verification, microtask reuse and exception reporting. |
What would establish a full match?
One traceable workflow must cover all seven ADA criteria: ordinary Windows observation; repetition discovery and a microtask proposal; user correction and trial approval; AI execution on a changed case with a verified result; reuse and combined-workflow tests; unattended execution and exception reporting; and fully self-hosted data, AI and execution.
A successful run on a changed case is required. Separate feature demonstrations or provider claims do not establish an end-to-end match.
Evidence status: linked source statements have been reviewed. Product behaviour and complete workflow results have not been verified by us. The comparison’s source reviews are dated 10–18 November 2026; product capabilities can change.